[UPDATE 12/29/08, 13:45 PST - new content added at the bottom]
This past weekend Seesmic CEO Loic Le Meur caused a bit of a fracas when he made a simple feature request for Twitter search. He wanted to be able to sort Twitter searches by the number of followers that a given user has, using that measure as some sort of indication of a user’s “authority”. That comment generated a surprisingly large and passionate amount of feedback from bloggers and Twitter users. Frankly, I was shocked that people felt so strongly about it, and I think Michael Arrington said it all with this post title: “Bloggers lose the plot over Twitter search“.
Be that as it may, it brings up a point that has long been talked about in the Twitterverse: how does one determine a Twitter user’s influence or authority?
Setting aside for a moment the question of whether or not we should even care about “authority” or influence on Twitter, I think that anyone advancing the notion of followers or followees as an accurate measure of influence is completely missing the mark. Twitter is social and interactive. The follower/followee model is overly simplistic. Sure, number of followers is interesting, since anyone with 15,000 followers has a “louder” voice than someone with 7, but what we still need is a dynamic, interactive measure.
Om Malik just posted an article about a study carried out by Bernardo Huberman (et al.) from HP’s Social Computing lab which examined the relationship between followers, followees (people a Twitter user follows), and “friends”. The study defined friends as people to whom a user has sent at least two @-replies.
As I have long suspected, measuring “friends”, as defined in the study, proved more meaningful a metric than simply counting followers or followees. A brief excerpt from Om’s post summarizes the study’s results:
On Twitter, [Huberman] found that regardless of the number of followers or followees, there were very few friends in a personal Twitter circle. He used a very weak definition of “friend” — anyone to whom a user has directed a post at least twice. And because of that, Huberman says that in order to “influence a person’s absorption of content, there is a need to find the hidden social network; the one that matters when trying to rely on word of mouth to spread an idea, a belief, or a trend.”
Huberman’s study found that:
- Users with a large number of followers are not necessarily those with very large number of total posts.
- Even though the number of friends initially increases as the number of followees increases, after a while the number of friends starts to saturate and stays nearly constant.
- The number of people a user actually communicates with eventually stops increasing while the number of followees can continue to grow indefinitely.
Interesting results, but still pretty obvious/intuitive. At least this study is getting closer to the heart of Twitter interaction and the influence its users have. After all, Twitter is a social tool, so just counting followers or followees doesn’t nearly capture the interactive nature of the service. Measuring “friends” (as defined above) gets closer, but I maintain that this still misses two very important measures. If, as Om assumes, we’re using the traditional definition of authority as the “power to influence or command thought, opinion or behavior”, then I propose that the following metrics are even more useful:
- Number of @-replies per post for a given user
- Number of “retweets” per post
As I stated in my comment on Om’s original post, I believe that one of the most important factors in a measure of authority or influence is the extent to which a user is able to get people thinking or talking about a topic. By that logic, a tweet which sparks a conversation and/or a large volume of replies should be given more weight than a tweet which goes out quietly and generates no responses.
To create a normalized metric which translates well across users with different numbers of followers we would ultimately need to collect data and see what kind of conclusions can be drawn from the metric above. We might find that it’s best to take the number of replies per post and multiply it by the ratio of followers who replied to the total number of followers. Or we might come to a different conclusion altogether.
The second metric I mentioned above is the number of re-tweets that a given post generates. Although they are less conversational in nature, re-tweets are interesting because they highlight tweets which someone not only found worthwhile, but found so compelling that (s)he wanted to pass it on to others. In fact, re-tweets are the core of Twitter’s ability to spread news at lightning speed. For example, in the recent terrorist attacks in Mumbai, Twitter was as good (if not better) a source of breaking news than any major cable news network.
I maintain, then, that any credible measure of Twitter authority has to take into account the spread of a re-tweeted post throughout the “Twitterverse”.
One of the main reasons I think my metrics are better than the “friend” metric defined in the HP study is because one can directly control (or even game) the friend count, whereas the reply/retweet metric is dependent on how other people perceive a given user.
For example, since “friends” are defined simply as people to whom one has directed two or more replies, I could start replying to tons of people throughout the Twitterverse, thereby increasing my friend count, but not really adding anything substantive to the community. Conversely, the reply/retweet metric is dependent on my ability to inspire and influence others. If I’m blathering on about pocket lint all day, my followers probably won’t find that noteworthy. Whereas if I’m funny, or a thought leader, or offering breaking news stories, my ability to inspire replies and retweets is likely to be much higher.
The bottom line is that while the study from HP’s Social Computing Lab is getting much closer to determining the influence of any given Twitter user, we really need more data to fully understand the interactive nature of Twitter and its users’ influence.
I would really like to see a more complete study which looks at the metrics I identified above. In fact, I have half a mind to get back to my statistics roots and put that ol’ masters degree to use in analyzing these metrics to see what conclusions can be drawn. If anyone wants to collaborate, drop me a line!
[UPDATE 12/29/08 - 13:45 PST]
It might not be obvious from my post above, so I wanted to go one step further and say that I don’t really think any single metric is sufficient to measure Twitter influence. While I strongly believe that two measures that I highlight above are more meaningful than follower count in a search for a proper influence metric, I think that they need to be looked at in context, and in combination with other measures (including follow numbers, total reach of a given tweet, etc.).
As a simple example, take the tweet from Loic which started this whole mess. Clearly it’s had a pretty major impact among the “Twitterati” and has elicited passionate feedback. But that didn’t just play out on Twitter. No, it’s been blogged, and retweeted, and remixed, and discussed both online and off (some would say ad nauseam). So perhaps any measure of Twitter “authority” is incomplete if it is confined to only measuring activity that plays out on Twitter.
One can extrapolate this problem even further and say that it’s directly related to the problem of measuring the full impact of anything that takes place on a blog, social network, or perhaps even the Internet. How does one measure the full impact of pay-per-impression advertising? Or a viral YouTube video? Or a popular blog post? Perhaps the best we can hope for is a good approximation.
Search
Social Bookmarking
Peter,
Interesting article. It’s a fascinating area for research, authority is a hugely subjective matter. One person’s authority is another’s minority.
I’d be interested to get your thoughts on the following blog post – and your readers too! All the best. M
http://tinyurl.com/7akqlc
You knew it had to happen: Start a Retweet Chain at http://www.RTchain.com
The authoritative point of view, curiously.. back lacks some details, right?
Bonjour, Polite to tie you, I am Julia
Для того, чтобы разместить хороший ролик, требуется очень много места, а место как раз ограниченно. А вот герою фильма “Подарок” выпала такая удача, да ещё какая: навороченный сотовый телефон с невероятным интеллектом способным просчитать практически все, что существует в природе. Кроме того, корпорация Билла Гейтса сообщила о покупке технологии FolderShare, позволяющей передавать по Сети файлы огромного размера. ? Вы там ее не обижаете?? Что ты, брат, ? возмутился Манвэ, ? конечно же, нет! Построили ей башенку, как она и хотела, выделили участок земли, так что твоя Элхэ живет себе припеваючи.
You here?! forward: “This is probably for someone in L.A. or a metro environment, but everyone loves leather. It’s actually a simple jacket, just the cut is a little unusual.” , Dresses Fashio Marine , Women’s T-shirts 2 Pieces RoccoBarocco or Pepe Jeans London Christian Audigier Women’s Tops T-Shirts for Men , Women’s Long Sleeve Tops Zu Elements UGG and G-Star LIU-JO BLUMARINE Scarfs & Hats , Girls Bacci Abbracci Club Cuba Rosanegra Brioni . of good purchases…!!!
I’m working with RPGMaker, and I want to do some recolouring. However, sometimes, I want to do a global recolour, and it’s quite annoying to do all pixels individually.
_____________
Szczury
Greetings I’m a new member and just wanted to say greetings. Send me a PM if anyone wanna chat sometime i’m available for conversations.
How come to move the mouse on you’re laptop, you can only use you’re finger? ive tried with a pen or a piece of paper covering my finger, among other things, but it only responds to my finger. Any ideas why?
_________________
Tapety na pulpit
http://www.wbtalisman.com
kupie mieszkanie
mieszkania sprzedaz
mieszkania bezposrednio
nieruchomosci bez posredników
sprzedaz mieszkan szczecin
nieruchomosci rynek pierwotny
nieruchomosci online
mieszkania na sprzedaz w warszawie
mieszkania do wynajecia kraków
nieruchomosci mieszkania blonie
kawalerka wynajem
pokój do wynajecia
Due to the solvent situation around the world sundry people take mature condensed times. They are either living paycheck to paycheck or are currently behind on bills and need a firm functioning to assail c promote cash. There are monotonous people that accept been recently laid nutty from their jobs without a system “B” to fragment assist on. According to CNNMoney.com “The percentage of those claiming that jobs are currently petrified to become reached further soprano of 49.6%, while the troop of consumers claiming that jobs are “plentiful” make an impact on a unknown deficient at 3.4%.” And according to the confidence guide of whether the situation intention rub someone up the wrong way better declined from 73.7 to 65.7 matrix month. And those in the club the nuisance trade in to climb up excel went from 18% to 16.3%. The economists suggest that Christmas spending will be down and that consumers purpose not regain spending conviction until time grow of next year.
What does that assuredly to us? It means that things will at best come by worst and many people are comparing this to the best unhappiness when people were borrowing the ready from the banks to venture in the stock market. When the stock trade in crashed they were not able to deliver abandon the banks the mazuma, which had a spill down effect. Today since so diverse mortgages are active bad the banks accept tightened their lending which is slowing down the economy. How has the saving contrived you? Be honest!
__________________
investments
I’m having to write a program to use the Bisection Method to calculate the roots of an equation. I pretty much have everything done for that part, but I don’t know how to read in an equation from the user. I need to be able to ask the user what the equation is that they are wanting to use, and then somehow convert it to a usable format. Someone told me that one of java’s preloaded classes has a tool to where you can read in the equation as a string, and java can plug in an ‘x’ value to find ‘y.’ That is what I’m kind of needing to do… Just something so that they enter in the formula and can plug in 2 values. What I tried doing was asking the user for the coefficients and storing them in an array. I then used a for loop to call back all the coefficients and multiply them by the ‘x’ value. Everything in my code says that it should work, but when I try running it, I guess it is too complex because it never returns an answer or even move on to the next step… Can anyone help make my life easier??? Thanks!
_________
Przepisy na ciasta
I’ve had my laptop for a little over a year now. My battery life use to last around 5 hours or so, now it only lasts 40 minutes. I’m like afraid I’m going to completely ruin the battery so that it wont work at all…. I have a Gateway laptop, is there any way i can get a new battery?
_______________
Transport pneumatyczny
Pref one that works with windows vista cuz I can’t find one that works. Plz help
___________________
Dentysta
Наша цель – быть полезными людям. Помоги детям инвалидам жить, ведь у них нет того чем наделила природа тебя… делаются периодические отчеты с фонда благотворительности.
Most people that earn money being an affiliate sign up with several Affiliate Programs. In fact, you may have to experiment with several before you find things that will make you the most money. One of the popular important consider when you choose to promote products as an affiliate is to choose worthwhile products. If you wouldn’t buy it or have any use for it chances are your customers won’t either. Remember, even though you’re selling on the internet and not in person, whether you truly believe in the products you are promoting will show through in your marketing efforts. Choose products that you truly believe in if you are planning to persuade others to buy them.
Regards,